Hotels in Hay Beach, Shelter Island from CA $109

Two of the best hotels in Hay Beach that receive consistently high recommendations from travellers are the American Beech Hotel and The Menhaden.

The 3.5-star American Beech Hotel, with an 8.8 rating, offers beautiful and clean rooms with premium bedding, Frette Italian sheets, and air conditioning. Guests appreciate the excellent amenities, including designer toiletries and bathrobes. The hotel also provides free bikes for exploring the area, and its location is praised as amazing, being just 0.3 km from the Greenport Carousel and 0.2 km from the Greenport Farmers' Market.

Another highly recommended option is the 3.5-star The Menhaden, which boasts an impressive 9.6 rating. Guests frequently praise the fantastic and friendly staff and the beautiful decor. This hotel offers complimentary breakfast, including self-serve options, and features premium bedding, bathrobes, and designer toiletries. It is also conveniently located, just 0.1 km from the Greenport Carousel and Camera Obscura.

Both of these hotels are highly rated and offer great convenience for travellers in Hay Beach.

For family-friendly hotels in Hay Beach, consider The Menhaden, The Harbor Front Inn, and American Beech Hotel.

The 3.5-star Menhaden, with an outstanding 9.6 rating, offers a free crib, child-friendly window design, and connecting rooms, making it very suitable for families. Guests can also enjoy complimentary breakfast, free bicycle use, and free parking nearby. It is conveniently located just 0.1 km from Greenport Carousel and Camera Obscura.

Another excellent option is the 3.5-star The Harbor Front Inn, rated 8.8. This hotel provides connecting rooms, free cribs, and a complimentary continental breakfast. It is also very close to popular attractions, being only 0.1 km from Greenport Carousel.

The 3.5-star American Beech Hotel, rated 8.8, is another great choice for families. It features child-friendly window designs, complimentary breakfast (including a to-go option), and free bicycle use. The hotel is located 0.3 km from Greenport Carousel.

For hotels in Hay Beach that offer complimentary breakfast, consider The Menhaden, The Harbor Front Inn, Stirling House Bed & Breakfast, and American Beech Hotel.

The 3.5-star The Menhaden, with an impressive 9.6 rating, provides free self-serve breakfast. Guests frequently comment on the friendly staff and beautiful decor. It is conveniently located near the Greenport Carousel, just 0.1 km away, and the Greenport Harbor Brewing Company, which is 0.4 km away.

Another excellent option is the 3.5-star The Harbor Front Inn, rated 8.8. This hotel offers a free continental breakfast. Travellers frequently praise its amazing location and good complementary breakfast, as well as the clean bathrooms and great coffee. Like The Menhaden, it is also very close to the Greenport Carousel (0.1 km) and the Greenport Harbor Brewing Company (0.4 km).

The 3-star Stirling House Bed & Breakfast, boasting an exceptional 9.8 rating, also includes free full breakfast for its guests.

Finally, the 3.5-star American Beech Hotel, with an 8.8 rating, offers a free to-go breakfast. Guests often highlight the beautiful and clean rooms, the great location, and the excellent amenities, including free bikes. It is situated 0.3 km from the Greenport Carousel and 0.1 km from the Greenport Harbor Brewing Company.

For top pet-friendly hotels in Hay Beach, consider The Menhaden, Zey Hotel, The Harbor Front Inn, and American Beech Hotel.

The 3.5-star The Menhaden, with an outstanding 9.6 rating, is a highly recommended option that permits pets. Guests frequently praise the friendly and fantastic staff, as well as the beautiful decor. It also offers a complimentary self-serve breakfast. It is conveniently located near the Greenport Carousel, Camera Obscura, and Greenport Farmers' Market, all within 0.2 km.

Another excellent choice is the 3.5-star Zey Hotel, which boasts a 9.2 rating and welcomes both dogs and cats. This hotel is situated close to the Greenport Carousel, Camera Obscura, and Greenport Farmers' Market, all within 0.3 km.

The 3.5-star The Harbor Front Inn, rated 8.8, is another great option that welcomes dogs. Guests appreciate the amazing location, the complementary and good breakfast, and the clean bathrooms. The hotel is very close to the Greenport Carousel, Camera Obscura, and Greenport Farmers' Market, all within 0.2 km.

The 3.5-star American Beech Hotel, also with an 8.8 rating, permits pets and provides food and water bowls. Guests often comment on the beautiful and clean rooms, the great location, and the excellent amenities, including a beautiful bar and free bikes. A complimentary to-go breakfast is also offered. It is within 0.3 km of the Greenport Carousel, Camera Obscura, and Greenport Farmers' Market.

For a highly-rated budget option in Hay Beach, the Stirling House Bed & Breakfast is an excellent choice.

This 3-star bed and breakfast, with an exceptional 9.8 rating, offers guests a very comfortable stay. You can enjoy complimentary full breakfast each morning, and free toiletries are provided. Free WiFi is available throughout the property, and convenient free self-parking is also offered, with additional free parking nearby.

For a romantic stay in Hay Beach, couples should consider The Harbor Front Inn and Stirling House Bed & Breakfast.

The 3.5-star The Harbor Front Inn, with an 8.8 rating, offers lovely rooms, some with a balcony. Guests frequently mention the excellent complimentary continental breakfast and the hotel's great location, which is close to the Norman E. Klipp Marine Park and Kontokosta Winery.

Another excellent choice is the 3-star Stirling House Bed & Breakfast, which boasts an outstanding 9.8 rating. It features rooms with sea views and a fireplace, creating a cosy and intimate setting. Guests also benefit from a complimentary full breakfast and free parking.

For hotels in Hay Beach near Norman E. Klipp Marine Park, consider The Menhaden, Zey Hotel, The Harbor Front Inn, and American Beech Hotel.

The 3.5-star Menhaden, with an impressive 9.6 rating, is located 1.3 km from Norman E. Klipp Marine Park. Guests appreciate the complimentary breakfast, including a self-serve option, and free bicycle use, which is ideal for exploring the area. The staff are frequently described as friendly and fantastic, and the decor is beautiful.

Another excellent option is the 3.5-star Zey Hotel, rated 9.2, which is just 0.9 km from Norman E. Klipp Marine Park. This hotel offers complimentary self-parking and bicycles, along with premium bedding and bathrobes for a comfortable stay.

The 3.5-star The Harbor Front Inn, rated 8.8, is also 1.3 km from the park. Guests enjoy the complimentary breakfast, including continental options, and free WiFi. The location receives high praise, and the rooms and bathrooms are noted for being beautiful and clean.

Finally, the 3.5-star American Beech Hotel, with an 8.8 rating, is located 1.0 km from Norman E. Klipp Marine Park. This hotel provides a complimentary breakfast, including a to-go option, and free bicycle use. Its location is highly rated, and the rooms are frequently described as beautiful and clean.

The best time to go to Hay Beach is during the shoulder seasons of late spring (May to early June) and early autumn (September to early October).

During these periods, the weather is pleasantly mild, and the crowds are notably smaller than in the peak summer months. You'll find it easier to secure preferred accommodation and dining reservations without the bustling atmosphere. The water is still warm enough for swimming in early autumn, and the natural beauty of the area is at its most appealing.

For those looking for the warmest weather and don't mind a livelier atmosphere, July and August are also excellent choices.

Many Expedia hotel reservations are refundable, provided that you cancel before the hotel’s cancellation deadline – this is often within 24-48 hours of your scheduled arrival. If you have a non-refundable booking, it might still be possible to receive a refund if you cancel it within 24 hours of booking. Be sure to check your booking confirmation for the exact cancellation policy. For maximum flexibility, use our "Fully refundable property" filter during your search to find the right Hay Beach hotel for you.

Hotel prices in Hay Beach often vary, but you can find a great deal from CA $109 on Expedia. Different factors affect nightly hotel rates, such as the time of year or the days of the week you want to book. To find the best deals for your stay, be flexible with your dates, and sort search results by "Price: low to high" for our cheapest rates.